| A |
Cap Anson, Ed Andrews, Al Atkinson |
| B |
Charlie Bennett, Oyster Burns, James Burke, Charlie Buffinton |
| C |
Jim Clinton, John Clapp, Fred Corey, Jim Conway |
| D |
Mike Dorgan, Abner Dalrymple, Daisy Davis, Hugh Daily |
| E |
Buck Ewing, Dude Esterbrook, Bob Emslie |
| F |
Jack Farrell, Joe Farrell, Dave Foutz, Curry Foley |
| G |
Barney Gilligan, Jack Glasscock, Fred Goldsmith, Pud Galvin |
| H |
Paul Hines, Pete Hotaling, Guy Hecker, Hardie Henderson |
| I |
Arthur Irwin |
| J |
Charley Jones, Jack (rl) Jones, Jack (da) Jones |
| K |
King Kelly, Joe Kappel, Tim Keefe |
| L |
Tom Lynch, Henry Larkin, Jack Lynch |
| M |
Tim Manning, Tommy McCarthy, Bobby Mathews, Larry McKeon |
| N |
Hugh Nicol, Candy Nelson, Tricky Nichols, The Only Nolan |
| O |
Dave Orr, John O'Rourke, Tip O'Neill |
| P |
John Peters, Martin Powell, Al Pratt |
| Q |
Joe Quinn, Joe Quest |
| R |
Jack Rowe, John Reilly, Lee Richmond, Charley Radbourn |
| S |
Gat Stires, Ezra Sutton, Charlie Sweeney, Dupee Shaw |
| T |
Jim Tipper, Dasher Troy, Billy Taylor |
| U |
|
| V |
Alex Voss, Peek-A-Boo Veach, John Valentine |
| W |
Podge Weihe, Jimmy Wolf, Jim Whitney, Sam Weaver |
| X |
|
| Y |
Ed Yewell, Tom York |
| Z |
|